Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
PARTY PACK FOR 4
CHEESECAKE WITH FRESH BERRIES
CHEESY GARLIC BREAD
MEATBALL PLATTER
About
Old Chicago Pizza Taproom Gillette
Welcome to Old Chicago Pizza Taproom Gillette, a hidden gem located at 1100 E Boxelder Rd, Gillette, WY 82718. This lively eatery has quickly won the hearts of locals and visitors alike. With a menu that boasts an impressive array of options—from hearty pizzas to delicious pastas, fresh salads, and mouthwatering burgers—it's no wonder that Old Chicago has become a favored dining destination in the area.
One of the standout features of Old Chicago is its inviting atmosphere. As noted by customer Jeffrey Gillespie, the curb appeal and layout contribute to a welcoming vibe, striking the perfect balance between being busy yet comfortable. The lighting enhances the ambiance, ensuring diners enjoy their meals without feeling overwhelmed. The staff here, praised for their exceptional service, creates an experience that leaves a lasting impression.
When it comes to the food, Old Chicago does not disappoint. Customer Robyn Bush expressed her delight with every aspect of her dining experience, which was so satisfying that it prompted a return visit the very next evening. The extensive menu offers a variety of choices to please every palate. For pizza lovers, the deep dish meat pizza is a fan favorite, consistently praised for its generous toppings and flavor, as highlighted by Yorkiemom4052. The calzones also shine, proving to be a delicious option for those seeking something a bit different.
In addition to great food, the bar at Old Chicago features a diverse selection of beers, ensuring that there is something for everyone. The attentive staff, like Haley, mentioned specifically by Jeffrey, make sure that every guest feels special and well-cared for throughout their meal. It's this combination of friendly service and delightful dishes that creates a homey vibe, as noted by Steven Eagle Feathers, who described it as the best place to hang out.
Whether you're seeking a casual dinner with friends or a family night out, Old Chicago Pizza Taproom Gillette is the place to be. Each visit promises a perfect blend of taste, atmosphere, and service that truly makes dining here a delightful experience. So why wait? Grab some friends, head over to Old Chicago, and indulge in everything this fantastic establishment has to offer!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Curb appeal was astonishing,layout inside and out was great. Very welcoming and inviting. Place got very busy yet still did not seem loud,cramped or like you were sitting a mile away or on top of someone else. Lighting was great not bright and not dim,could see perfectly without feeling like in a spotlight.Staff started off great and only got better. Looked hard to find any weak points, we found none. Menu item pics looked perfect and described in a very boasting way. Well think they misquoted, everything was even better than advertised and may have even been modest in advertising. In short, from begining to end, from first step to last step, from menu to table, from first bight to last bight and from first impression to last impression ....perfection. All staff were great. Haley was our server though and what a terriffic person. Haley you were and I am sure you will always be an amazing person. May God bless you all. ”
“ We truly enjoyed our first experience here. Everything was amazing, from the service to the food and cleanliness. We liked it so much, we went back the next evening!! ”
“ First time going there! Great food, large menu! Pizza, pasta, salads, wraps, burgers and a great bar, and a very wide variety of beers. Envelopes in the family loved their choice of food. Wait staff was very attentive! ”
“ Stopped by for dinner. I love their deep dish meat pizza. It’s consistently tasty and has a good deal of toppings. My husbands calzone was delicious. Our server was on the ball with refills and checked on us often. ”
“ The staff was fun and polite. We had a great time. Sid was great and made it feel like home. Best place to hang out with good food and atmosphere. ”
“ We ordered pizza and pretzel sticks for pickup on our way back to hotel, both were good. There was a small delay but Kaylee took care of it promptly with great customer service. We sat down for a beer with the very personable and knowledgeable bartender Bryn while we waited for our takeout order. Would definitely go back. ”
“ We were on the road trip and stayed in the area for one night. Since we got to the city late at night (9:30ish), a lot of restaurants had been closed. They took us in and let us order right before the kitchen closed. The staffs were friendly. The food was very tasty and the price is reasonable. I will recommend this place. ”
“ This was our first visit to Old Chicago Pizza as we travel full time in RVs. We had the chance to stop in Gillette for one night and were amazed with the friendly services. Maddie was our smiley server and she just enhanced our time spend at this restaurant. We suggest both, stop at Old Chicago Pizza in Gillette and ask for Maddie. We will be back. Pamela and Michael ”